Don’t Trust Government to Keep Deals

President Trump decided to withdraw from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, also known as the Iran Nuclear Agreement, and his critics are enjoying their opportunity to show concern.

You can debate whether the deal had any legitimacy, whether it was a good idea, and what breaking the deal means, but you’d be missing the point. Agreements are meaningless to governments.

Every government, or rather every person imagining themselves a representative of a government, feels they have the right to make and break deals. Every government sees itself as special and believes anything they do is justified. It’s the same if the deal is between governments or between a government and an individual.

There is no downside for a government to agree to a deal, so it is quick to agree and quicker to break them when they become inconvenient.

Just ask anyone who isn’t a government extremist how well the U.S. government has obeyed its Constitutional limitations — the charter that allowed it to exist.

Or ask the Native people of America how well the treaties they agreed to were kept.

Ask yourself what happened with Social Security numbers, which were promised to never become any sort of national identification number and made illegal to use for identification outside of Social Security, but which are now national identification numbers.

Governments feel no obligation to live up to their agreements while demanding you keep up your end centuries after their betrayal.

A problem with making any agreement with government is that you have no real recourse when the government tires of its end of the bargain. Even if your complaint is heard, it will either be heard by a representative of the same government that cheated you — a representative who owes his job and paycheck to your opponent — or by some other government. No government wants to find governments obligated to keep their end of any deal. It could come back to bite them. Obviously, seeking justice on your own would be called a crime by the government that violated you.

If you make an agreement with a government and expect the agreement to be honored, you have set yourself up for disappointment. If you expect agreements between two or more governments to be upheld, you seem unaware of what government is or how it works. Don’t expect a scorpion to act like anything other than a scorpion. Not even if you consider it your pet.

Save as PDFPrint

Written by 

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments