Why Not Rectify Past Injustices?

I just got back from a month in the UK, working for the John Locke Institute‘s two summer schools.  The morning before I left, I delivered my talk on “The Economics of Antipathy and Stereotyping.” In the subsequent Q&A, one of the students asked (roughly), “But shouldn’t we try to rectify past injustices that caused present-day differences in worker productivity?”  Since I wasn’t satisfied with my answer at the time, here are the three key points I wish I’d made.

Thinking about Energy

Before we can decide whether something is good or bad, we need a standard. Good for what or whom? Moreover, in environmental matters it makes a difference whether you see mankind as an invader and destroyer of benignly stable nature or as a species that flourishes by taming often dangerously volatile nature, that is, making it a safer, more hospitable place.

Getting It Wrong

Maybe the battle of the sexes will never end.  Maybe if it does, it will be like Vietnam or Afghanistan.  With a WTF? My complaint has always been that the only winners seem to be the ones who act the most like the aggressors.  Women who wear pants suits, and men who are the most passive aggressive win (in an odd way).