Government– specifically, statism– is irrational. Let’s look at what “rational” means:
1. agreeable to reason; reasonable; sensible:
a rational plan for economic development.
2. having or exercising reason, sound judgment, or good sense:
a calm and rational negotiator.
3. being in or characterized by full possession of one’s reason; sane; lucid:
The patient appeared perfectly rational.
4. endowed with the faculty of reason:
5. of, relating to, or constituting reasoning powers:
the rational faculty.
I already see a flaw. “a rational plan for economic development“. If it’s a plan which involves anti-economics– politics– it isn’t rational. And you know that’s the kind of “plan” they are referring to. This is why I’ll check dictionary definitions, but don’t automatically trust them. They have a lot of biases included.
But, back to the irrationality of government.
Government, specifically statism, is not “agreeable to reason”. If it were, there would be no statists. Instead, it is based on a superstition; a “just so” story written to explain something in a fictional manner to simpletons who are assumed to be too stupid to understand reality.
You can’t disprove it with reason because it isn’t based on reason. It is based on feelings and wishes. This is why the perfectly logical, reasonable, sensible, ethical statement “taxation is theft” sways so few statists. They are not agreeable to reason.
And the rest of the definition hinges on that first one. Government fails the first one so it, therefore, fails them all.
Government is irrational.